Recent high-profile media stories about dog attacks have given certain breeds a bad name all over again.
But is it really about the breed?
As soon as such attacks happen, people wonder, "What provoked this dog?" Some say, "It's the dog's fault."
Is it really?
All dogs, if unsocialized with humans and other dogs, can revert to instinct if they are abused and/or kept in captivity (i.e. tied up for long hours, locked in basements, etc.) Dogs aren't born with the knowledge and experience to realize they shouldn't act aggressively toward other dogs or humans. They're products of their upbringing - just like children.
And yes, it's true. Some breeds, including pit bulls and other "bully breeds," are high-energy, high-drive dogs that, if unsocialized, can revert to instinct to deal with a stressful situation. They have a higher likelihood of behaving aggressively in response to stress because they were bred to respond to stress triggers with aggression.
Any dog - including a pit bull - can be a well-behaved, good canine citizen if it's properly socialized from the start. And any dog - including a golden retriever - can become aggressive if confronted with stress (a confrontational dog, a kid pulling a tail) and not properly socialized.
As some have said, such "bully" breeds require highly knowledgeable owners capable of handling them and raising them properly, including socializing them so they are used to other dogs and people.
But, unfortunately, pit bulls and similar breeds are often targets for irresponsible owners -- people who want them as status symbols, or watchdogs, or both, or worse, for dog fighting. This is not the breed's fault. It's our fault as a society for not doing more to stop irresponsible dog ownership.
There is a dog in my neighborhood that is chained to a tree for 10 to 12 hours a day, rain or shine. Many of us have called, and animal control has visited several times. Today, as I left for work, the dog was still tied up - in the rain - and barking uncontrollably. Could anyone blame that dog for being frustrated and lashing out at someone? Honestly, I fear for kids, adults and other dogs in our neighborhood. If that dog got off-leash, it probably would go ballistic. And I wouldn't blame the dog. I'd blame its irresponsible owners.
Let's tighten up the laws on dog ownership. It shouldn't take two or three warnings -- or the death of a child -- to wake people up and make them realize that the way animals are treated undoubtedly affects the way they interact with the rest of the world.
Do you agree or disagree? Share your opinions here!


Control your dog -- that's...
Back to page topControl your dog -- that's the key. Train your dog well, and deaths probably won't happen. If the pup goes berzerk, then the owner should be smart enough to know that it's time to put it to sleep. I know a family whose beloved dog bit the baby, and the pooch isn't around anymore. People are more important than canines -- that's the bottom line.
Whether governmental policies ought to be involved is a different question completely ...
(Mathias Baden is the editor of the Jordan Independent. He can be reached at editor@jordannews.com.)
Thank you for such a well...
Back to page topThank you for such a well written article!
There are thousands of the dogs targeted by breed legislation that are loving caring dogs because they have been handled responsibily according to that breed's needs.
Any doubt of this could be offset by watching the YouTube video guarenteed to touch your heart here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MuyNNdELsDA and by reading about the thousands (over 10,000 so far actually) of dogs and dog owners who have been helped by addressing their behavior challenges using the information and techniques if National Geographic Channel's Cesar Millan here:
http://pets.groups.yahoo.com/group/DogWhispererFans/ ! We have seen over and over how ever the worst case dogs can be turned around by applying the appropiate psychology and behavior modifications, and then followed up by consistent reinforcement by the owners!
Dogs that are well exercised, socialized, and taught rule and limitations which are consistent do not have these kinds of problems!
Thank you so much for an...
Back to page topThank you so much for an actual FACTUAL article on bull and terrier breeds. I have a 4 year old American Staffordshire Terrier. My family adopted him from a rescue when he was one. He is hyper and playful and active and loving and well-mannered. He has never met a stranger, and everyone who meets him and is initially leery of him due to media stereotypes leaves with their minds completely changed due to his true nature.
Your dog is what YOU make it. Every dog attack can be traced directly back to an IRRESPONSIBLE OWNER that either taught their dog to be mean, or allowed their dog to run loose unsupervised. Every dog bite involving a child can be traced directly back to an irresponsible PARENT and/or OWNER, sometimes both the same person, who allowed their child and/or dog to play unsupervised. Until legislators get that through their heads and focus on irresponsible owners, there will always be problems with dogs (ANY type) being aggressive.
Thank you for such a well...
Back to page topThank you for such a well written article!! We need to see more articles like this. Its all about owners, not about dogs. People train dogs, not the other way around. We need to focus more on owners than on any specific breed. This is not a pitbull problem. It is an irresponsible owner problem!!! People out there need to wake up and realize once they get what they want, and the pitbull and other "dangerous" dogs are banned, there will just be a new breed deemed dangerous and they will be targeted next. Its my breed of choice they are after today, could it be yours next?
I agree that training has a...
Back to page topI agree that training has a huge impact on how any dog behaves.
That said, how much do you think instinct plays a role in any breed of dog being aggressive?
Dogs are protective by nature of "their humans", their yards, their toys, etc.
I think larger dog breeds are scary to me because if they give in to instinct its 200 lbs., not 45 lbs or 5 lbs., of dog to handle. Their strength makes large dog breeds intimidating and risky.
I don't think dog breeds should be banned, but with all of the dog attacks lately, it's clear that owners of large dogs need to be aware of that difference.
We can't kid ourselves about the logistics. Large dogs have the potential to do more damage. That doesn't mean they will. Owners of such powerful animals need to be dilligent in training and monitoring their dog's behavior and exposure to other people.
Training is a big part,...
Back to page topTraining is a big part, indeed...but it's not just training - it's socialization and making sure your dog is as comfortable as possible around many types of people and dogs. That and making sure your dog sees you as the leader and knowing that when you give a command, he or she will obey it!
Thank you Lori and Mathias...
Back to page topThank you Lori and Mathias for your comments. It is nice to see "sane" discussion on this very touchy subject. Being as how I grew up with dogs my whole life (from Old English Sheepdogs to Pugs) this is a hot button subject for me.
Yes - training and socialization are the key. Let the dog know where he stands in his "pack" and all is well. However, to answer Mathias - YES city and township governments should be involved however slightly. For instance, Prior Lake has a "dangerous dog" ordinance that spells out that if a dog attacks a human and it is an unprovoked attack, the owner is responsible (fined, conditions put on the dog remaining in the community etc). The ordinance is a smart one because it is not breed dependant. I've been around mean Toy Poodles. Size does not matter....damage can still be done! Basing the ordinance on individual means that the responsible Bull Terrier owners can still have their dogs and the irresponsible owners are put on notice that THEY are the ones responsible for their dogs.
Cindy
Training and socialization...
Back to page topTraining and socialization is very important. I agree. Yet also, many people pick the wrong dog for their lifestyle.
You need to take that into account. If you are a lazy, couch potato, getting any type of terrier dog probably isn't a good idea. That breed is high energy and the dogs need exercise. And exercise is very important in training your dog and getting to behave. A tired dog is more apt to listen to you.
All dogs should be walked, but some breeds are higher energy. People should take that into account when selecting a dog. It's not grocery shopping.